In 2009, I had the extraordinary privilege of sitting down one-on-one with John C. Bogle at WHYY-TV in Philadelphia.
Over the years, I’d spent many hours interviewing Jack, and to say I learned so much from him would minimize the time spent. But this particular interview was special. An entire hour of John Bogle giving a national audience of everyday investors the chance to hear his wisdom firsthand.
To appreciate what it was like in 2009, just remember how frightening things were back then. Wall Street was in free fall. Lehman Brothers had collapsed. Banks were failing, credit markets were freezing, and Americans were watching half of their hard-earned savings disappear almost overnight.
The numbers were staggering and shocking. An estimated $16 trillion in household wealth had vanished. The S&P 500 had plunged nearly 57% from its peak. Millions of Americans were losing their jobs, their homes, and most importantly, their confidence in the US financial system.
All you heard were headlines screaming the sky was falling. Yet there sat Jack Bogle, calmly explaining to us why the biggest threat to our financial futures might be our own emotions.
Fast-forward to November 3, 2026
Another hard-fought midterm election. Another round of stock market turmoil. And this time, artificial intelligence is at the center of it all. And the turmoil from last week’s midterm results doesn’t compare to the 2009 financial crisis. But it doesn’t have to. Fear and uncertainty have a way of getting under investors’ skin, no matter what’s driving the headlines.
Investors can be in love with AI stocks one day and the next, they’re questioning whether these trillion dollar AI companies have gotten out ahead of themselves.
Maybe they have. But that’s exactly why it’s worth looking beyond today’s headlines and remembering what history’s taught us. Since 1950, the S&P 500 has gained an average of roughly 15% in the 12 months following midterm elections, with positive returns after all 19 elections through 2022.
I’m repeating this stat from my last Substack on purpose, because it’s worth hearing again that political anxiety and long-term investment returns don’t go hand in hand.
Here’s a Number Worth Remembering
On March 9, 2009, the S&P 500 closed at 676.53. On November 6, 2026, it closed at 7,376.86.
That’s nearly eleven times higher. A gain of roughly 990%, before dividends.
Think about everything investors have lived through during those seventeen years. A pandemic, rising inflation, rising interest rates, a middle class squeeze, wars, elections. And now AI.
Nobody could have predicted all of it. And that’s precisely Jack Bogle’s point.
Successful investing isn’t about our ability to predict what happens next. It’s about the fundamentals. It’s how you divide your assets. It’s diversification, keeping costs low, having a sensible and resilient financial plan, and resisting the urge to just abandon it whenever fear takes the wheel.
Fifty Years of Proving the Skeptics Wrong
There’s another reason Jack deserves our attention this year. 2026 marks the 50th anniversary of the first index mutual fund he launched for individual investors.
When Jack introduced it in 1976, he hoped to raise $150 million. He raised just $11.3 million. Wall Street dismissed the idea as “Bogle’s folly.”
Today, trillions of dollars are invested in low-cost index funds. Think about how millions of ordinary investors have built wealth. He made that possible. Jack didn’t just revolutionize investing. He changed the financial futures of generations of Americans.
This is why I’m bringing this interview back into the spotlight right now.
Markets change, technologies change, Presidents and Congresses come and go. Human nature? Not so much.
Seventeen years later, every word of Jack’s wisdom feels as fresh and relevant as it did when we sat together in Philadelphia.
And I can’t think of a better time to hear it again.
P.S. If you’d like to explore how a vetted, fiduciary advisor can help you create your own financial plan, you can access Wealthramp’s network anytime.



